Looking for the best rated replacement windows? Here are the best rated windows from Consumer Reports. For additional information, see what industry experts consider the —
Best Rated Replacement Windows
1. Highest Ratings For Wood Clad – Marvin Clad Ultimate. Consumer reports scored this 88 out of 100.
2. Highest Ratings For Vinyl – Survivor Reliabilt 5600. Consumer reports scored this 73 out of 100.
3. Highest Ratings For Fiberglass Windows Pella Impervia Consumer reports scored this 87 out of 100.
Best Rated Replacement Windows 2010 – Vinyl – From Consumer Reports
Survivor Reliabilt 5600 (Lowe’s)
Rating: 73
Retail Cost $180
0 Degree Resistance: Very Good
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Very Good
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Excellence
Alside UltraMaxx Replacement
Grade: 70
Retail Cost $395
0 Degree Resistance: Very Good
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Good
How Durable: Excellent
Conventience Rating: Excellent
American Craftsman 9500 Series (from Home Depot)
Rating: 69
Retail Cost $220
0 Degree Resistance: Very Good
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Very Good
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Excellent
CertainTeed Bryn Mawr II
Grade: 63
Retail Cost $250
0 Degree Resistance: Very Good
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Very Good
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Excellent
CertainTeed New Castle XT (Similar to Bryn Mawr II)
Rating: 63
Retail Cost $250
0 Degree Resistance: Very Good
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Very Good
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Excellent
Crestline CrestFit Vinyl
Grade: 61
Retail Cost $255
0 Degree Resistance: Very Good
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Good
How Durable: Excellent
Conventience Rating: Good
Pella ThermaStar 25 Series
Rating: 44
Retail Cost $215
0 Degree Resistance: Poor
70 Degree Resistance: Poor
How Rain Resistant: Very Good
How Durable: Excellent
Conventience Rating: Very Good
Best Rated Window 2010 – Wood
Marvin Clad Ultimate
Grade: 88
Retail Cost $400
0 Degree Resistance: Excellent
70 Degree Resistance: Excellent
How Rain Resistant: Excellent
How Durable: Excellent
Conventience Rating: Good
Marvin Wood Ultrex Integrity
Rating: 87
Retail Cost $315
0 Degree Resistance: Excellent
70 Degree Resistance: Excellent
How Rain Resistant: Excellent
How Durable: Excellent
Conventience Rating: Very Good
Andersen 400 Series Tilt-Wash
Grade: 85
Retail Cost $350
0 Degree Resistance: Excellent
70 Degree Resistance: Excellent
How Rain Resistant: Excellent
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Good
Pella ProLine
Rating: 82
Retail Cost $215
0 Degree Resistance: Excellent
70 Degree Resistance: Excellent
How Rain Resistant: Very Good
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Good
Andersen 200 Series Tilt-Wash
Grade: 80
Retail Cost $235
0 Degree Resistance: Excellent
70 Degree Resistance: Excellent
How Rain Resistant: Excellent
How Durable: Good
Conventience Rating: Good
Pella Designer Series Precision Fit
Rating: 79
Retail Cost $600
0 Degree Resistance: Very Good
70 Degree Resistance: Excellent
How Rain Resistant: Excellent
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Good
Peachtree 500 Series
Grade: 76
Retail Cost $350
0 Degree Resistance: Very Good
70 Degree Resistance: Excellent
How Rain Resistant: Very Good
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Very Good
Crestline Select Clad
Rating: 66
Retail Cost $340
0 Degree Resistance: Very Good
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Fair
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Good
Weather Shield Weather Shield
Grade: 56
Retail Cost $395
0 Degree Resistance: Poor
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Excellent
How Durable: Good
Conventience Rating: Good
Weather Shield Custom Shield
Rating: 56
Retail Cost $395
0 Degree Resistance: Poor
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Excellent
How Durable: Good
Conventience Rating: Good
JELD-WEN Premium Wood Tradition Plus
Grade: 50
Retail Cost $360
0 Degree Resistance: Poor
70 Degree Resistance: Very Good
How Rain Resistant: Very Good
How Durable: Very Good
Conventience Rating: Very Good
Highest Ratings For Fiberglass 2010
Pella Impervia
Rating: 87
Retail Cost $255
0 Degree Resistance: Excellent
70 Degree Resistance: Excellent
How Rain Resistant: Very Good
How Durable: Excellence
Conventience Rating: Very Good
Related Topics
Calculate Your Next Project Cost
Find RW Costs
5 Rules For Getting An Estimate
